Good Pine P.C.

All Insights

Practical legal guidance on litigation, business law, employment, formation, nonprofit law, and estate planning — for businesses and individuals in New York and New Jersey.

Buy-Sell Agreements: How to Set the Rules for a Business Divorce Before It Happens

Designing effective buy-sell provisions for New York and New Jersey closely held businesses: common failures in existing operating agreements, triggering events (death, disability, voluntary departure, involuntary termination with for-cause distinction, deadlock with shotgun and right-of-first-offer mechanisms), fixed price and formula and appraisal valuation methodologies, life insurance funding through entity purchase and cross-purchase structures, installment payment provisions, rights of first refusal, tag-along and drag-along rights, non-compete enforceability, and the interaction between contractual provisions and BCL Sections 1104-a and 1118 and N.J.S.A. 14A:12-7.

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

What Happens When Business Partners Can't Agree on Value: Appraisal Clauses, Court-Appointed Experts, and the Litigation Path in New York and New Jersey

Dispute resolution mechanisms for business valuation disagreements in New York and New Jersey: contractual appraisal clauses and their enforceability, court-appointed neutral appraisers under BCL Section 1118 and N.J.S.A. 14A:12-7, the structure of dueling expert litigation, the BCL Section 1118 procedural sequence from petition through the 90-day election window, mediation timing and strategy, the Section 1118 election decision, and the deferential appellate standard for judicial valuation determinations.

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

Goodwill in Business Buyouts: Why Personal Goodwill and Enterprise Goodwill Are Valued Differently in New York and New Jersey Disputes

Personal versus enterprise goodwill in professional practice buyout disputes: what each category is and why the law treats them differently, New York's approach under Friedman v. Beway and Grunfeld v. Grunfeld, New Jersey's approach under Dugan v. Dugan and N.J.S.A. 14A:12-7, the role of non-compete agreements, the evidentiary factors courts examine (client origination data, post-departure attrition, operational systematization, referral relationship structure), buy-sell agreement goodwill provisions, and the federal tax implications of the personal/enterprise split.

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

How Is a Business Valued in a New York or New Jersey Buyout or Shareholder Dispute?

How closely held businesses are valued in New York and New Jersey buyout and shareholder disputes: fair value under BCL Section 1118 and Friedman v. Beway (no minority or marketability discounts) versus fair market value in contractual buyouts (discounts of 20–40%), NJ oppression remedies under N.J.S.A. 14A:12-7 and Balsamides v. Protameen, the three valuation methodologies, the dollar impact of minority and marketability discounts, operating agreement valuation provisions, and personal versus enterprise goodwill.

Read More
Litigation, Business Law & Contracts Sung-Min Lee Litigation, Business Law & Contracts Sung-Min Lee

Your Arbitration Clause Just Got More Powerful: What Jules v. Balazs Means for Business Contracts

This article explains the Supreme Court's May 14, 2026 decision in Jules v. Andre Balazs Properties, No. 25-83, which unanimously holds that a federal court that stayed claims under FAA Section 3 retains jurisdiction to confirm or vacate the resulting arbitration award under Sections 9 and 10, without requiring the confirmation motion to independently establish federal jurisdiction. It covers the FAA's arbitration framework including the mandatory stay requirement under Smith v. Spizzirri, the distinction between Jules (prior federal lawsuit followed by arbitration) and Badgerow v. Walters (freestanding confirmation without prior federal lawsuit), the narrow substantive grounds for vacating an award under FAA Section 10, arbitration clause drafting considerations including scope, delegation, institutional rules, seat, governing law, and emergency relief carve-outs, post-award enforcement strategy including the Section 9 one-year confirmation window, and collectibility assessment before and after arbitration.

Read More
Litigation, Employment Sung-Min Lee Litigation, Employment Sung-Min Lee

NY and NJ Sexual Harassment Standards: What Korean Employers Need to Know About Mandatory Policies, Training, and Liability

This article explains the sexual harassment obligations that New York and New Jersey impose on Korean employers, going well beyond the federal Title VII baseline. It covers the NYSHRL's 2019 amendment eliminating the severe or pervasive standard, the NYCHRL's broader liability framework applicable to NYC employers with four or more employees, New York State's mandatory written sexual harassment prevention policy requirements and annual training obligations for all employees regardless of size, New Jersey LAD's extension of individual personal liability to supervisors and managers who engage in or enable harassment, the specific investigation and documentation obligations triggered within 72 hours of receiving an internal complaint, the retaliation prohibition from the moment a complaint is made, Korean workplace cultural patterns — hierarchy-based informality, 회식 culture, and gender role task assignments — that create unintended legal exposure under U.S. standards, and the four components of a compliant employer: written policy, annual training, documented complaint procedure, and prompt investigation protocol.

Read More
Employment, Litigation Sung-Min Lee Employment, Litigation Sung-Min Lee

My Business Was Just Served With an Employment Discrimination Complaint — First Steps for NY and NJ Employers

This article explains the seven immediate steps a New York or New Jersey employer must take upon receiving an employment discrimination complaint: identifying the type of proceeding and applicable deadlines (twenty-one days in federal court, twenty or thirty days in New York Supreme Court, thirty-five days in New Jersey Superior Court); refraining from all contact with the complainant to avoid retaliation exposure; issuing an immediate litigation hold covering physical and electronic documents including KakaoTalk and messaging app communications; notifying the EPLI carrier and requesting coverage confirmation; engaging employment defense counsel immediately; gathering and organizing the factual record under attorney-client privilege without reconstructing or backdating documents; and making an early, honest assessment of the claim's merits and settlement value before significant litigation costs accumulate.

Read More
Employment, Litigation Sung-Min Lee Employment, Litigation Sung-Min Lee

Individual Liability Under the NJ Law Against Discrimination: When Managers Get Sued Personally

This article explains how New Jersey's Law Against Discrimination imposes individual personal liability on owners, managers, and supervisors who personally participate in discriminatory conduct under N.J.S.A. 10:5-12(e)'s aiding and abetting provision. It covers which individuals face personal exposure — owners, store managers, and supervisory employees — the conduct that triggers individual liability including discriminatory termination, hostile work environment harassment, retaliation, and failure to accommodate disability or pregnancy, the full scope of damages recoverable from individual defendants including compensatory damages, emotional distress, punitive damages, and mandatory attorneys' fees, EPLI insurance coverage limitations for individual defendants, and practical steps Korean business owners and managers can take to reduce personal exposure including documentation practices, complaint response protocols, culturally aware conduct standards, and supervisory training.

Read More
Employment, Litigation Sung-Min Lee Employment, Litigation Sung-Min Lee

Wage and Hour Liability for Korean-Owned Businesses: The Five Most Common Violations

This article identifies the five wage and hour violations most commonly committed by Korean-owned businesses in New York and New Jersey: misclassifying employees as independent contractors under the FLSA, NYLL "suffer or permit" standard, and New Jersey's ABC test; failing to pay overtime to non-exempt employees including salaried workers; illegal tip pooling and improper tip credits under New York and New Jersey law; failing to provide wage notices and pay stubs as required by New York's Wage Theft Prevention Act; and failing to maintain accurate time and payroll records. It also addresses personal liability of owners under the FLSA and NYLL's broad definition of "employer."

Read More
Nonprofit Law, Litigation Sung-Min Lee Nonprofit Law, Litigation Sung-Min Lee

When a Church Breaks From Its Denomination: Building, Bank Accounts, and Name in New York and New Jersey

This article explains how courts in New York and New Jersey resolve property disputes when a local church breaks from its denomination. It covers the distinction between hierarchical and congregational polity, the deference rule established in Watson v. Jones and Presbyterian Church v. Hull, the neutral-principles approach adopted in Jones v. Wolf, 443 U.S. 595 (1979), express trust clauses and their enforceability, deed analysis and presumptions of local ownership, financial asset disputes and restricted fund obligations, church name rights under state corporate law and federal trademark law, and the steps a congregation should take before and after a denominational break including UCC lien searches, review of denominational polity documents, and corporate governance updates.

Read More
Nonprofit Law, Litigation Sung-Min Lee Nonprofit Law, Litigation Sung-Min Lee

When Church Members Sue the Church: Derivative Claims, Removal of Officers, and Internal Dispute Resolution in New York and New Jersey

This article explains the legal mechanisms available to church members in New York and New Jersey when they believe church leadership has engaged in financial misconduct or violated the church's governing documents. It covers the distinction between direct and derivative claims, the demand requirement under N.Y. N-PCL Section 623 and N.J.S.A. 15A:5-9, fiduciary duties of directors under N-PCL Section 717, judicial removal of directors for cause under N-PCL Section 706(d) and N.J.S.A. 15A:6-12, the ten-percent membership threshold for removal petitions, contested elections under N-PCL Section 619, member inspection rights under N-PCL Sections 620 and 621 and N.J.S.A. 15A:5-24, improper membership termination as a direct claim, the First Amendment neutral-principles framework and its limits on court jurisdiction, and internal dispute resolution including mediation before litigation.

Read More
Nonprofit Law, Litigation Sung-Min Lee Nonprofit Law, Litigation Sung-Min Lee

Who Controls the Church? Board Authority, Pastor Authority, and Governance Disputes in New York and New Jersey Nonprofits

This article explains how authority is legally allocated in a church nonprofit under New York and New Jersey law. It covers board authority under N.Y. N-PCL Section 701 and N.J.S.A. 15A:6-1, the New York Religious Corporations Law's dual governance structure, the First Amendment's neutral-principles-of-law framework established in Jones v. Wolf, 443 U.S. 595 (1979), the sources and limits of pastoral authority including written employment agreements and board delegation, quorum and notice requirements for valid board action under N-PCL Section 707, the N-PCL holdover rule under Section 703(d), judicial remedies for contested board elections under N-PCL Section 619, and practical steps when a board-pastor conflict arises including emergency court relief.

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

Korean Companies in U.S. Contract Disputes: How to Defend a Claim and Sue for Breach in New York and New Jersey

This article explains how Korean companies should navigate U.S. contract disputes on both sides of the dispute. It covers the fundamental differences between U.S. and Korean contract practice including the parol evidence rule, no-oral-modification clauses under New York General Obligations Law Section 15-301, and course of dealing principles; defendant obligations including answer deadlines in New York Supreme Court, New Jersey Superior Court, and federal court, statute of limitations defenses under CPLR Section 213(2) and UCC Section 2-725, and common contractual defenses; plaintiff strategy including demand letters, forum selection, diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332, collectibility assessment, and prejudgment attachment under CPLR Article 62; and jurisdiction and governing law including enforcement of choice-of-law clauses under New York General Obligations Law Section 5-1401, application of Korean law in U.S. courts, mandatory versus permissive forum selection clauses under M/S Bremen and Atlantic Marine, and personal jurisdiction over Korean defendants.

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

ICC Arbitration for Korean Companies with U.S. Commercial Contracts: A Practical Guide

This article explains ICC arbitration for Korean companies with U.S. commercial contracts. It covers the ICC's 2021 Arbitration Rules, arbitration clause drafting including seat, governing law, and number of arbitrators, common seats for Korea-U.S. disputes including New York and Singapore, Request for Arbitration procedures, tribunal constitution and co-arbitrator nomination, document production under IBA Rules, the ICC scrutiny process for draft awards, ICC administrative and arbitrator fee structures, enforcement of ICC awards in U.S. federal courts under Chapter 2 of the Federal Arbitration Act implementing the New York Convention, enforcement in Korea under the Korean Arbitration Act, emergency arbitrator relief under the ICC Rules, and strategic considerations including language, co-arbitrator selection, and the distinction between ICC and KCAB International.

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

Settling a Business Dispute Without Going to Court: Mediation, Arbitration, and Negotiation in New York and New Jersey

This article explains the three principal alternatives to litigation for New York and New Jersey business disputes — negotiation, mediation, and arbitration. It covers the confidentiality protections for mediation under CPLR Section 4547 and the New Jersey Uniform Mediation Act N.J.S.A. 2A:23C-1, arbitration clause enforceability under the FAA and New York law, AAA and JAMS commercial arbitration procedures, the narrow grounds for vacating an arbitration award under CPLR Article 75 and N.J.S.A. 2A:23B-23, enforcement of awards under N.J.S.A. 2A:23B-22, and a practical framework for choosing among dispute resolution methods based on contract terms, amount in dispute, and relationship considerations.

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

NJ Consumer Fraud Act: Per Se Violations Explained

This article explains per se violations of the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act (CFA), N.J.S.A. 56:8-1 et seq. It covers the structure of the CFA and its three categories of prohibited conduct, the distinction between per se regulatory violations and general unconscionable conduct claims, the regulatory scheme at N.J.A.C. 13:45A governing advertising, home improvement practices, and other industries, the mandatory treble damages and attorneys' fees remedy under N.J.S.A. 56:8-19, the ascertainable loss requirement, the Home Improvement Practices regulations at N.J.A.C. 13:45A-16, the six-year statute of limitations under N.J.S.A. 2A:14-1, and defenses available to businesses including lack of ascertainable loss, inapplicability to commercial transactions, and absence of proximate causation.

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

Demand Letter vs. Lawsuit: When Does a Business Dispute Escalate to Litigation in New York and New Jersey?

This article explains the role of the demand letter in New York and New Jersey commercial disputes and the factors that drive the decision to escalate to litigation. It covers demand letter strategy and content, the statute of limitations for contract claims under CPLR Section 213(2) and N.J.S.A. 2A:14-1, court selection across New York's Small Claims Court, Civil Court, Supreme Court, and Commercial Division, New Jersey's Special Civil Part and Complex Business Litigation Program, federal diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332, arbitration under the FAA, mediation, and how businesses should respond when they receive a demand letter.

Read More
Litigation, Employment Sung-Min Lee Litigation, Employment Sung-Min Lee

Wrongful Termination Claims in New York: What Employers Need to Know

This article explains the legal framework for wrongful termination claims in New York from the employer's perspective. It covers the at-will doctrine and its contractual limits, discrimination claims under Title VII, the ADEA, the ADA, the post-2019 NYSHRL, and the NYCHRL, retaliation claims and the whistleblower protections of NYLL Sections 740 and 741, damages including compensatory and punitive awards under the NYSHRL and NYCHRL, individual supervisor liability, best practices for documenting termination decisions, and the OWBPA requirements for enforceable releases of ADEA claims under 29 U.S.C. § 626(f).

Read More
Litigation, Employment Sung-Min Lee Litigation, Employment Sung-Min Lee

My Employee Filed an Unpaid Wage Claim in New York — What Do I Do?

This article explains what New York employers should do when an employee files an unpaid wage claim. It covers the legal framework under the New York Labor Law and FLSA, the forums in which wage claims are filed including the NYSDOL and federal court, the six-year statute of limitations under the NYLL, liquidated damages and attorneys' fees exposure, personal liability for LLC members under NYLL Section 198-a, immediate steps including document preservation and litigation hold, common violations including overtime misclassification and independent contractor misclassification, and settlement considerations including the FLSA court approval requirement under 29 U.S.C. § 216(b).

Read More
Litigation Sung-Min Lee Litigation Sung-Min Lee

TRO vs. Preliminary Injunction: What New York and New Jersey Businesses Need to Know

This article explains the difference between a temporary restraining order (TRO) and a preliminary injunction for businesses in New York and New Jersey. It covers the three-factor state court standard and the four-factor federal standard, TRO procedures and duration limits under CPLR 6301 and Federal Rule 65(b)(2), the undertaking requirement under CPLR 6312(b), common commercial contexts for emergency relief including non-compete enforcement and asset dissipation, appellate rights under CPLR 5701(a)(2) and 28 U.S.C. § 1292(a)(1), and how to defend against an emergency injunction application.

Read More